An underground mining operation had been struggling with their Six Sigma program. The program had been underway for about 12 months and for various reasons had struggled to gain traction. 12 projects had been selected and were progressing at various paces. In mining, tons is king and this mine was no different – maximise throughput safely over all other objectives.
We know that not all improvement projects are created equal. By that we mean that only projects that are run at the process bottleneck increase the throughput of the whole process. Projects run on non-bottleneck operations will not increase throughput. The business had identified 4 projects that focused on the bottleneck, with the remaining projects in other areas of the business. The key project on the process bottleneck was the ‘SAG’ mill project.
In this case study we’ll focus on how we used Designed Experiments (DOE) to achieve the throughput increase. Designed Experiments are a key tool (see our Process Improvement Toolbox), used to improve processes and can be used both in operational projects and occasionally in transactional projects. This case study will not detail every step that was completed on the project.
The Sag mill in question is essentially a large rotating drum, approximately 10 metres in diameter, and 7 metres in depth. Crushed Ore is fed into the centre of the rotating drum, and subsequently drops to the outside of the Drum. The SAG mill drum has several tons of Iron Balls (each about 100mm in diameter) in the centre of the barrel, that are lifted up as the drum rotates and then as the ball gets over the 90 degree point the balls drop onto the Ore at the bottom of the drum, crushing the ore. Once the crushed ore is crushed to a small enough size, it flows out of the SAG mill and onto the next step in the process. The SAG mill was controlled from a control room which was continuously manned.
Measure the current Process
Initially we started by confirming that the Sag Mill operation was in fact the bottleneck of the process. Once confirmed that we were working on the correct process step we moved to mapping the process.
We mapped the process by walking the process to witness its operation for ourselves. During this visit to the ‘Gemba’ (the place where the work is done), we were able to talk to the operators, trying to build a practical understanding how the SAG mill was operated. Our Gemba visit showed that the control room operators each operated the Mill in a different way and usually the the first thing an oncoming shift would do was alter the control settings used by the previous shift.
We had formed an improvement team, who verified the process map and helped to develop a cause and effect diagram to identify all of the potential reasons we were unable to hit the target throughput rates. Prioritisation of the causes of low throughput resulted in eight potential causes of low throughput rates being identified. We were then able to generate our Goal tree diagram.
One of the potential reasons for low throughput was the lower than optimum volume of Balls (called Ball Charge) in the SAG mill -the more balls in the mill, the more crushing the mill should achieve. This would turn out to be the critical factor in determining Mill throughput.
To cut to the chase, it was then decided that we needed to run a designed experiment. Why was this deemed necessary?
A Designed Experiment (called DOE) is a set of trials that are run in a controlled manner. The SAG Mill settings are changed, run up to stable state and then the resulting impact on the process output can be reviewed. One of the advantages of a DOE is that the factors can be changed all at once and we can work out the impact of each factor on the output. Without DOE we would have had to resort to making small changes to each input factor one at a time -much slower than Designed Experiments.
We are also not limited to only measuring one output, we can have multiple outputs. A DOE is a planned experiment, with the DOE being run on real time data versus a regression model that uses historical data. We had previously applied a regression model to the data but the process exhibited a great deal of noise and the results were meaningless. The other benefit of DOE is that you do not need to have much knowledge of the process. You do need to ensure that you have chosen the correct factors; hence why you need to involve operators who understand the process.
We should point out that the Sag Mill was like a black box where no one knew the exact relationship between the potential causes and throughput rates. We had reduced the potential causes(Factors) down from eight to four, Ball Charge Volume, Power (power supplied to the Electrical Motor rotating the Drum), Sound Level (the noise of the balls crushing the ore) and Ore Feed Rate (rate the ore was fed into the drum). We ran what is called a full factorial experiment, meaning a full combination of input changes would be trailed; in our case 16 combinations of input settings.
Running our DOE
The Control Room operators understood how to change the variables but not the mathematical relationship between the settings of the Inputs and throughput. This is where DOE are a fantastic tool. You don’t need to understand much about the process. When we made a change in the SAG mill input settings it took up to two hours for the output to stabilise. It would take approximately 30 hours to complete our DOE.
We ran the experiment, collecting data, and analysing that data. The DOE outcomes were:
- A mathematical model predicting SAG mill throughput rates based on input settings.
- Optimised input factors setting that would maximise Mill throughput and minimise variation.
- Determined the relative importance of each of the input factors.
- Increased throughput by 26% for a four hour period.
- Provided inputs into new Standard Operating Procedures.
- Gained knowledge about the process that we could build upon for future improvements.
- Moved the process bottleneck to another step in the process.
There is no doubt that a Designed Experiment is one of the best tools in the business improvement professionals toolbox. If you can run a DOE then successful results are almost a certainty. If you want to learn more about how DOE can help you, reach out to us on our ‘contact us’ page. We have some upcoming DOE training-keep an eye out on our homepage or twitter feed for further details.